Assessing discards in an illegal small-scale fishery using fisher-led reporting
Author(s)
Jaime Mendo
Janneke Ransijn
Iván Gómez
Patricia Gil‐Kodaka
Judy Ann H. Fernandez
Ruggeri Delgado
Alejandra Travezaño
Ruggeri Arroyo
Karla Loza
P. McCann
Sean A. Crowe
Esther L. Jones
Mark James
Date Issued
28 de marzo de 2022
Type
Article
Volume
32
Issue
3
Start Page
963
End Page
974
Abstract
About a third of all marine fish in the world are caught in Small-Scale Fisheries (SSF). SSF are increasingly recognised as essential for food security and livelihoods for vulnerable and economically fragile communities globally. Although individual SSF vessels are usually perceived as having little impact on the ecosystem, the cumulative impact of gear type and number of vessels may be substantial. Bottom trawling is a common fishing method that can greatly influence the marine ecosystem by damaging the seafloor and generating high levels of discards. However, appropriate sampling coverage using on-board observer programmes to collect these data from SSF are rare, as they are expensive and pose logistical constraints. A mobile App was used to assess whether self-reporting by fishers could provide reliable fine-scale information on fishing effort and discards over time in an illegal shrimp trawling fishery in northern Peru. Maps depicting the spatial distribution of trawling effort and the proportion of discards from observers and fishers were compared using the Similarity in Means (SIM) Index, which ranges from 0 when spatial patterns differ completely to 1 when spatial patterns are very similar. High levels of agreement between spatio-temporal patterns of effort (SIM Index = 0.81) and discards (0.96) were found between fisher and observer maps. Moreover, far greater spatial coverage was accomplished by fishers, suggesting that self-reporting via an App represents a useful approach to collect reliable fisheries data as an initial step for effective monitoring and management of these fisheries. Supplementary Information: The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s11160-022-09708-9.